• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Cahoots Restaurant Fayetteville - Historic Dining with Reasonable Prices & Fresh American Fare

Cahoots Restaurant, located in historic downtown Fayetteville, TN, offers a unique dining experience set in a beautifully transformed old county jail. Known for its warm atmosphere and attentive service, Cahoots serves a diverse menu featuring standout dishes like perfectly cooked ribeye steak, crispy onion rings, and the highly praised club sandwich. Fresh salads and generous portions complement the hearty entrees, all at reasonable prices. While some diners note mixed experiences with ambiance, many appreciate the blend of Southern comfort food with a touch of elegance. Cahoots is a go-to spot for those seeking quality, flavor, and a memorable meal in Fayetteville.

Cahoots Restaurant at a glance

  • Address 114 Market St W, Fayetteville, TN 37334, United States
  • Phone +1 931-433-1173
  • Restaurant type American restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Cahoots Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings

Maggie Moon
5

Cahoots was recommended by a friend. It was our 1st visit. We had the onion ring appetizer. Ribeye Steak, shrimp, and a burger/fries. The steak and shrimp came with a salad, and potato. The onion ring appetizers came out very quickly, and were hot and very delicious. Good portion size. The salad was crisp fresh, and they brought plenty of dressing. All the food was cooked perfectly to order. The value was excellent. When compared to most restaurants, and inflation.... the prices were very reasonable here. Our server was so fast, and efficient! It was a very good experience.

Rubin Reviews
4

3.5⭐ - great price, nice place I think it is the place to go in Fayetteville for a more “fancy” meal. The place is a transformed county jail. They have a wide range of food choices. I loved my club sandwich and fried dill pickles. Their taco salad and fried cheese was just so-so.

Beth Fiorucci
5

My husband and I went tonight for our first time. We have recently moved to Lincoln county from Huntsville. We very much enjoyed our dinner as well as the atmosphere. Our server was great and the prices were very reasonable. We will definitely be back!

Kelly Watts
4

It was OK. I've wanted to go for a long time. Finally went with a gal pal. I didn't see the old jail decor or atmosphere I expected. But the 2 of us were seated at a old diner type table for 6 in the front corner even though the place wasn't half full. So maybe there was better atmosphere elsewhere. It was just us and the flies where we were.

Margaret Conners
5

Visited Cahoots today for lunch with relatives visiting Huntsville from Syracuse, NY. We chose this location in historic downtown Fayetteville as a meeting place since the rest of our group was from Nashville, Franklin, and Murfreesboro. What a great lunch (best club sandwich ever, tuna salad delicious, catfish fingers yummy). Our waitress was perfect as well as the atmosphere of the old jail. Be sure to eat here if ever in the Fayetteville area. After eating you can visit the antique stores around the square!

Femalej777 Femalej777
5

$4 and sum for loaded cheese fries. Like the price. For the amount I will buy again. Good snaking without feeling too tired eating a full lunch. 1st time getting food. Customer service was nice and knowledgeable about menu. Have not tried anything else just yet. Will post pictures when I get more from the menue/. 9/20/22- Steak salad. Added green peppers ans extra tomatoes. Is delicious. 9/27/22 = today was a steak potato with extra Tomato. No milk products. So no cheese no sour cream.extra bacon bits too was $16.97

Chris Hill
5

My wife was in the area and wanted to try something different. So I drove 30 miles to meet up with her. It was a very nice looking place. The service was great. The food had large portions and tasted great. It was well worth my drive and I will be back.

Cheryl Smith
5

Lacey is the best been there 19 years and her daughter works the front and just as sweet!!! Good food.

Location

  • Cahoots Restaurant
    Cahoots Restaurant
    114 Market St W, Fayetteville, TN 37334, United States Hotline: +1 931-433-1173

Nestled in the heart of Fayetteville, Tennessee, Cahoots Restaurant offers a unique dining experience that blends history with hearty, well-crafted meals. Housed in a beautifully transformed old county jail, this spot carves out its own niche as a go-to destination for those seeking elevated comfort food without the pretension. The ambiance, rich with stories of the past, creates an inviting backdrop that complements the menu’s diverse offerings.

From the moment you arrive, Cahoots impresses with prompt service and a warm atmosphere. The star of the meal often begins with their onion rings—crispy, hot, and generously portioned, they set a high standard early on. Highlights include tender ribeye steak and succulent shrimp, each plate accompanied by fresh salads and perfectly cooked potatoes, illustrating their commitment to quality and balance. The club sandwich and catfish fingers have earned praise as well, blending familiar flavors with just the right touch of Southern charm.

What stands out at Cahoots is the seamless combination of great value and thoughtfully prepared dishes. Reviewing customer feedback, it’s clear that the kitchen respects both tradition and craftsmanship, aiming to please a varied palate with classic items like burgers and fries alongside more refined choices. While a few guests have noted areas for atmosphere improvement, many find the historic setting and attentive service add a special layer to the dining experience.

Whether you’re meeting friends or enjoying a quiet night out, Cahoots delivers a satisfying, approachable menu that respects the local heritage and modest prices. It’s a refreshing pick for Fayetteville visitors or locals wanting a taste of something both familiar and distinctive. After your meal, be sure to explore the charming downtown square and its antique shops, rounding out a visit steeped in Southern hospitality and flavor.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Offers kerbside pickup
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards